| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9:35.11 | March 1, 2021 | Mason McCauley | - |
| 9:35.11 | March 1, 2021 | Mason McCauley | Titan Cup |
| 9:51.82 | Jan. 24, 2020 | Mason McCauley | Illinois Wesleyan vs. Millikin, North Central |
| 9:56.40 | Jan. 10, 2020 | Mason McCauley | Illinois Wesleyan vs. Wabash |
| 10:00.61 | Jan. 16, 2010 | Chris Betzle | DePauw vs. Illinois Wesleyan, Franklin |
| 10:02.84 | Nov. 1, 2008 | Chris Betzle | Wabash, Rose-Hulman @Illinois Wesleyan |
