| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:47.12 | March 22, 2024 | Julien Camy | NCAA Division III Championship |
| 1:47.44 | Feb. 24, 2024 | Eric Chimes | MIAA Championships |
| 1:48.94 | Dec. 2, 2023 | Eric Chimes | Calvin Winter Invitational |
| 1:49.29 | Feb. 19, 2022 | Julien Camy | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:49.35 | Dec. 3, 2021 | Julien Camy | Calvin Winter Invite |
| 1:49.80 | March 12, 2021 | Julien Camy | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Men's Championships |
| 1:51.28 | Feb. 20, 2016 | Brett Stoughton | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:52.40 | March 20, 2015 | Brett Stoughton | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 1:52.51 | March 21, 2014 | Brett Stoughton | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 1:53.19 | Dec. 6, 2013 | Brett Stoughton | Calvin College Invitational |
| 1:55.50 | March 19, 2010 | Mark Rushlow | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 1:59.23 | Dec. 4, 2009 | Mark Rushlow | Calvin Invitational |
| 2:07.61 | Nov. 1, 2008 | Keith Conrad | Calvin @Albion |
