| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2:00.07 | Dec. 2, 2023 | Caleb Gemmen | Calvin Winter Invitational |
| 2:00.09 | March 21, 2015 | Johnson Cochran | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 2:00.44 | March 22, 2014 | Johnson Cochran | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 2:03.19 | Feb. 15, 2014 | Johnson Cochran | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 2:03.27 | Dec. 7, 2013 | Johnson Cochran | Calvin College Invitational |
| 2:05.09 | Feb. 16, 2013 | Johnson Cochran | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 2:07.07 | Feb. 18, 2012 | Travis Vincent | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 2:09.68 | Dec. 3, 2011 | Stephen Kraft | Calvin Invitational |
| 2:10.43 | Feb. 19, 2011 | Stephen Kraft | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 2:11.53 | Dec. 4, 2010 | Stephen Kraft | Calvin Invitational |
| 2:13.20 | Feb. 13, 2010 | Stephen Kraft | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 2:16.00 | Dec. 5, 2009 | Stephen Kraft | Calvin Invitational |
| 2:20.42 | Nov. 7, 2009 | Stephen Kraft | Calvin vs. Wheaton |
| 2:22.44 | Nov. 14, 2008 | Keith Conrad | Calvin @Olivet |
