| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:45.25 | Feb. 24, 2024 | David Bajwa | MIAA Championships |
| 1:47.87 | Dec. 2, 2023 | David Bajwa | Calvin Winter Invitational |
| 1:49.51 | Nov. 4, 2023 | Charles Platt | Calvin Quad |
| 1:49.78 | Dec. 3, 2022 | Timothy Hays | Calvin Winter Invitational |
| 1:49.84 | Feb. 24, 2018 | Ben Holstege | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:50.76 | March 19, 2016 | Skyler Fish | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 1:50.86 | Feb. 20, 2016 | Skyler Fish | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:51.97 | Feb. 14, 2015 | Skyler Fish | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:52.42 | Dec. 4, 2014 | Tanner Vincent | Calvin Winter Invitational |
| 1:53.44 | Feb. 15, 2014 | Andrew Mitchell | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:54.37 | Feb. 18, 2012 | Ross Battoclette | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:59.32 | Feb. 18, 2011 | Stephen Kraft | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association Championships |
| 1:59.50 | Dec. 5, 2009 | Kyle Garringer | Calvin Invitational |
| 2:03.60 | Nov. 1, 2008 | Ross Battoclette | Calvin @Albion |
| 2:05.49 | Oct. 31, 2008 | Ross Battoclette | Calvin @Grand Valley |
