| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9:26.56 | Feb. 18, 2017 | Tanner Vincent | - |
| 9:57.74 | Nov. 9, 2013 | Aaron Venema | Calvin vs. Wheaton (Illinois) |
| 10:01.94 | Oct. 26, 2012 | Aaron Venema | Calvin vs. Grand Valley State |
| 10:10.72 | Jan. 29, 2010 | Ross Battoclette | Calvin vs. St. Mary's (IN) |
| 10:19.02 | Jan. 9, 2010 | Mathias Bares | Calvin vs. Olivet |
| 10:23.80 | Nov. 1, 2008 | Ross Battoclette | Calvin @Albion |
| 10:54.44 | Oct. 31, 2008 | Ethan Tatum | Calvin @Grand Valley |
