| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5:01.10 | Feb. 9, 2017 | Maddie Prangley | North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| 5:01.78 | Dec. 3, 2016 | Maddie Prangley | Fredonia Blue Devil Invitational |
| 5:01.98 | Feb. 21, 2015 | Maddie Prangley | Kenyon Fast Chance Invitational |
| 5:02.36 | Feb. 12, 2015 | Maddie Prangley | North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| 5:06.66 | Feb. 22, 2014 | Maddie Prangley | Kenyon College Invitational |
| 5:13.44 | Feb. 10, 2011 | Jennifer Meltz | North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| 5:15.05 | Feb. 11, 2010 | Laura Fries | North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| 5:17.84 | Nov. 21, 2009 | Grace Aheron | Oberlin vs Allegheny |
| 5:20.30 | Nov. 13, 2009 | Grace Aheron | Veale Classic |
| 5:30.21 | Jan. 24, 2009 | Bryne Ulmschneider | OWU Invite |
| 5:30.73 | Jan. 17, 2009 | Kelsey Sherman | John Carroll & Allegheny @Oberlin |
| 5:35.92 | Nov. 22, 2008 | Bryne Ulmschneider | Oberlin @ Baldwin-Wallace |
