| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9:48.97 | Feb. 3, 2024 | Matt Stevens | Ithaca vs. SUNY-Geneseo vs. Union (NY) |
| 9:56.12 | Feb. 2, 2013 | Bob Towner | Ithaca vs. Union (New York) |
| 9:57.93 | Jan. 19, 2013 | Bob Towner | Ithaca vs. Rochester |
| 10:01.42 | Jan. 14, 2012 | Bob Towner | RPI Kumpf Invitational |
| 10:09.55 | Oct. 15, 2011 | Bob Towner | Ithaca vs. Fredonia State, Ithaca, Nazareth, SUNY-New Paltz |
| 10:33.98 | Jan. 22, 2011 | Josh Leary | Ithaca vs. Rochester |
| 10:39.62 | Nov. 21, 2009 | Matthew Carolan | Hamilton vs. SUNY-Geneseo, Ithaca , Hartwick |
