| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4:18.35 | March 15, 2017 | Arthur Conover | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 4:20.95 | March 18, 2015 | Arthur Conover | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 4:25.07 | March 18, 2009 | Kegan Borland | NCAA Division III Championships |
| 4:25.62 | March 15, 2007 | Eric Dunn | NCAA Division III Mens Championships |
| 4:30.42 | March 16, 2006 | Eric Dunn | NCAA Division III Mens Championships |
