| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5:04.28 | Feb. 9, 2023 | Logan Schohn | Old Dominion Athletic Conference Championships |
| 5:07.37 | Dec. 3, 2022 | Logan Schohn | Yellow Jacket Invitational |
| 5:19.25 | Feb. 11, 2022 | Nate Viricochea | Old Dominion Athletic Conference Championships |
| 5:21.85 | March 5, 2021 | Nate Viricochea | Old Dominion Athletic Conference Championships |
| 5:32.12 | Nov. 23, 2019 | Maxwell Currens | Randolph-Macon/Yellow Jacket Invitational |
| 5:38.49 | Feb. 15, 2019 | Maxwell Currens | Old Dominion Athletic Conference Championships |
| 5:49.22 | Jan. 26, 2019 | Maxwell Currens | Hollins vs. Guilford vs. Randolph vs. Virginia Wesleyan |
| 5:49.25 | Dec. 1, 2018 | Maxwell Currens | Washington & Lee Invitational |
| 6:09.67 | Nov. 11, 2018 | Maxwell Currens | Virginia Wesleyan vs. Hampden-Sydney, Sweet Briar |
| 6:26.75 | Dec. 2, 2017 | Patrick McKneely | Washington & Lee Invitational |
| 6:34.38 | Nov. 4, 2017 | Patrick McKneely | Virginia Wesleyan vs. Roanoke |
