| Name | Team | Time | Pts | Imp | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Danny Lynch |
 Washington & Lee
|
1:56.93 | 614 | +3.9% | PB | |
| 2 | Jesse Tate |
 York (PA)
|
1:57.75 | 601 | -0.7% | ||
| 3 | Morgan Schreiber |
York (PA)
|
1:58.08 | 596 | – | PB | |
| 4 | Jared Nickodem |
Washington & Lee
|
1:59.10 | 581 | -0.3% | ||
| 5 | Ben Brown |
Washington & Lee
|
1:59.82 | 571 | +2.3% | SB | |
| 6 | Nolan McARDLE |
 Messiah
|
2:01.59 | 546 | +1.8% | SB | |
| 7 | Thomas Caldwell |
Washington & Lee
|
2:01.77 | 544 | -0.6% | ||
| 8 | Noah Schammel |
Washington & Lee
|
2:02.18 | 538 | +0.1% | SB | |
| 9 | Gabriel Penn |
York (PA)
|
2:03.00 | 527 | -1.1% | ||
| 10 | Glaucio Silva |
York (PA)
|
2:03.82 | 517 | +0.8% | SB | |
| 11 | Andrew Newman |
York (PA)
|
2:04.86 | 504 | -1.9% | ||
| 12 | Michael Federline |
York (PA)
|
2:06.29 | 487 | +2.0% | PB | |
| 13 | Oscar Onoszko |
 Randolph
|
2:06.99 | 479 | +0.1% | PB | |
| 14 | Jason Maccannon |
Messiah
|
2:09.61 | 451 | +0.1% | SB | |
| 15 | Colin McKinnon |
Washington & Lee
|
2:10.24 | 444 | -1.8% | ||
| 16 | Kurtis Platteel |
Messiah
|
2:10.62 | 440 | +0.3% | PB | |
| 17 | Anthony Pompei |
Messiah
|
2:11.36 | 433 | – | ||
| 18 | Jacob Robinson |
York (PA)
|
2:15.68 | 393 | +0.5% | SB | |
| 19 | ANDREW SCALES |
Randolph
|
2:16.00 | 390 | +1.5% | PB | |
