| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2:07.55 | Feb. 4, 2024 | Ashley Connor | IAAM A & B Conference Championship |
| 2:07.76 | Jan. 13, 2024 | Ashley Connor | National Catholic High School Championships |
| 2:08.89 | Jan. 26, 2013 | Deanna Parsons | 13 National Catholic HS Championship |
| 2:11.15 | Jan. 28, 2012 | Deanna Parsons | 12 National Catholic High School Championships |
| 2:12.58 | Jan. 29, 2011 | Deanna Parsons | NATIONAL CATHOLIC H.S. CHAMPIONSHIPS |
| 2:23.74 | Jan. 26, 2008 | MEGHAN PETERSEN | NATIONAL CATHOLIC H.S. CHAMPIONSHIPS |
| 2:25.46 | Jan. 27, 2007 | RACHEL HARBARGER | NATIONAL CATHOLIC H.S. CHAMPIONSHIPS |
