| Name | Time | Date | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jiwh Noel Santos | 55.75 | Nov. 16, 2019 | Malone Invitational |
| Javier Sanchez | 56.73 | Jan. 14, 2017 | Battle of the Hills: Buckhannon |
| Austin Pillado | 57.27 | Jan. 16, 2016 | Davis and Elkins vs. WV Wesleyan |
| Austin Pillado | 58.13 | Oct. 17, 2015 | Frostburg State vs. Davis and Elkins, Hampden-Sydney, Gallaudet |
