| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:35.67 | Feb. 13, 2020 | Quentin, Reynolds, Knoch, Williams | Great Midwest-Mountain East Conference Championship |
| 1:36.39 | Feb. 14, 2019 | Reynolds, Butterworth, Kenny, Quentin | Great Midwest-Mountain East Conference Championship |
| 1:37.67 | Feb. 15, 2018 | Quentin, Reynolds, Butterworth, Kenny | Great Midwest-Mountain East Conference Championship |
| 1:39.39 | Nov. 30, 2017 | Quentin, Reynolds, Butterworth, Kenny | Wooster Invitational |
| 1:39.90 | Dec. 4, 2014 | Bently, Jankowska, Friedrich, Brookens | Wooster Invitational |
| 1:41.90 | Dec. 5, 2013 | Bently, McCue, Parker, Brookens | Wooster Invitational |
| 1:42.99 | Feb. 7, 2013 | Brookens, Swartz, Duncan, Jankowska | Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference |
| 1:49.86 | March 4, 2011 | Perry, Duncan, Wagner, Groves | NAIA National Championships |
| 1:50.17 | Jan. 8, 2011 | Groves, Duncan, Wagner, Perry | Lake Erie vs. Alma, Malone |
| 1:50.98 | Nov. 19, 2010 | Perry, Duncan, Groves, Wagner | John Carroll Invite |
| 1:54.17 | March 5, 2010 | Hower, Kuhn, Radnich, Wagner | NAIA National Championships |
| 1:54.59 | Feb. 20, 2010 | Hower, Kuhn, Radnich, Wagner | Last Chance Meet: Kenyon |
