| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1:43.63 | Nov. 4, 2022 | Carter Stulhmacher | FHSAA Florida 3A State Championship |
| 1:43.73 | Oct. 28, 2022 | Carter Stulhmacher | FHSAA 3A Region 2 |
| 1:44.69 | Nov. 9, 2018 | Ben Stark | FHSAA 3A State Championship |
| 1:44.88 | Nov. 4, 2016 | Sam Hartle | Florida 3A State Championships |
| 1:46.14 | Nov. 13, 2015 | Sam Hartle | Florida 3A State Championships |
| 1:48.07 | Nov. 5, 2015 | Sam Hartle | FHSAA Class 3A - Region 2 Championships |
| 1:50.24 | Oct. 29, 2014 | Sam Hartle | FHSAA Class 3A Championships - Region 2 |
| 2:01.41 | Nov. 8, 2013 | Sam Hartle | 14 Florida Regional Championships Class 3A - Region 2 - (Winter Haven) |
