| Time | Date | Name | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15:40.12 | Feb. 18, 2018 | John Tepper | Metropolitan Championships |
| 15:53.45 | Feb. 19, 2017 | John Tepper | Metropolitan Championships |
| 16:04.42 | Feb. 21, 2016 | John Tepper | Metropolitan Championships |
| 16:13.66 | Feb. 22, 2015 | Zachary Wister | Metropolitan Championships |
| 16:19.63 | Nov. 30, 2012 | Zachary Wister | Swarthmore Invitational |
| 17:10.00 | Feb. 19, 2012 | Gary Hessler | Metropolitan Championships |
| 17:18.51 | Dec. 2, 2011 | Gary Hessler | Swarthmore Invitational |
| 17:20.85 | Feb. 21, 2010 | Kyle Banks | Metropolitan Championships |
| 17:30.66 | Dec. 6, 2009 | Kyle Banks | Franklin & Marshall Invitational |
