| Name | Time | Date | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steve Stuthers | 1:55.00 | Feb. 11, 2016 | 2016 North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| Steve Stuthers | 1:55.14 | Feb. 14, 2013 | 2013 North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| AJ Burt | 1:57.30 | Nov. 30, 2012 | DePauw Invitational |
| Brendan Eggers | 1:59.14 | Feb. 10, 2011 | North Coast Athletic Conference Championships |
| Michael Garza | 2:00.11 | Feb. 20, 2010 | Last Chance Meet: Kenyon |
| Conor O'Rourke | 2:00.22 | Dec. 4, 2009 | DePauw Invitational |
| Phil Bambach | 2:01.86 | Dec. 5, 2008 | 2008 DePauw Invitational |
| Phil Bambach | 2:06.19 | Nov. 1, 2008 | Wittenberg @Wooster |
