| Name | Time | Date | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ryan Schaum | 4:42.15 | Feb. 22, 2019 | NESCAC Mens Championships |
| CJ Murdoch | 4:42.41 | Feb. 25, 2011 | New England Small College Athletic Conference Mens Championships |
| Adam Eramo | 4:48.35 | Feb. 26, 2010 | New England Small College Athletic Conference (M) Championships |
| Adam Eramo | 5:00.64 | Jan. 30, 2010 | Wesleyan vs. Bowdoin College and Colby College |
| Adam Eramo | 5:05.21 | Dec. 5, 2009 | Cardinal Invitational |
| Adam Eramo | 5:05.34 | Nov. 22, 2008 | Wesleyan, Bates @Trinity (CT) |
