| Name | Time | Date | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Max Shoyat | 1:51.66 | Feb. 14, 2019 | Southern Athletic Association Championships |
| Max Shoyat | 1:54.40 | Nov. 16, 2018 | Wabash College Invitational |
| John Kelley | 1:56.41 | Feb. 12, 2015 | 2015 Southern Athletic Association Championships |
| Spencer Vetter | 1:57.33 | Feb. 14, 2013 | 2013 Southern Athletic Association Championships |
| Shawn Malony | 1:58.25 | Feb. 17, 2011 | Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference Championships |
| Shawn Malony | 1:59.89 | Feb. 18, 2010 | Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference Championships |
| Hunter Owen | 2:03.59 | Nov. 20, 2009 | Hilltopper Invitational |
| Hunter Owen | 2:03.61 | Oct. 17, 2008 | Butler, Centre @ IUPUI |
