| Name | Time | Date | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Riley Griffis | 4:28.50 | Feb. 17, 2023 | NESCAC Mens Championships |
| Riley Griffis | 4:31.36 | Feb. 18, 2022 | NESCAC Mens Championships |
| Kevin O'Rourke | 4:32.76 | March 31, 2009 | – |
| Kevin O'Rourke | 4:33.81 | March 18, 2009 | 2009 NCAA Division III Championships |
| Kevin O'Rourke | 4:34.39 | March 20, 2008 | 2008 NCAA Division III Mens Championship |
