| Name | Time | Date | Meet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Luke McNamara | 4:01.39 | Feb. 24, 2024 | NESCAC Mens Championships |
| Nick Keenan | 4:08.15 | Feb. 23, 2013 | 2013 New England Small College Athletic Conference Mens Championships |
| Nick Keenan | 4:09.26 | Feb. 26, 2011 | New England Small College Athletic Conference Mens Championships |
| Zachary DeVore | 4:16.20 | Feb. 27, 2010 | New England Small College Athletic Conference (M) Championships |
| Harrison D Anixter | 4:30.79 | Nov. 21, 2009 | Middlebury vs. Connecticut, Tufts |
