| Name | Team | Time | Pts | Imp | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ambert Sawaya |
 Kenyon
|
1:39.79 | 763 | +0.3% | PB | |
| 2 | Christopher Rutter |
Kenyon
|
1:41.10 | 734 | -1.1% | ||
| 3 | Eric Gerlach |
 Denison
|
1:41.23 | 731 | +0.3% | PB | |
| 4 | Mitchell Stahara |
 Westminster
|
1:42.26 | 709 | -2.2% | ||
| 5 | Matt Hedman |
Denison
|
1:42.35 | 707 | – | PB | |
| 6 | Kenny Fox |
Denison
|
1:43.85 | 677 | – | PB | |
| 7 | Bebe Wang |
Denison
|
1:44.01 | 674 | -3.8% | ||
| 8 | Karl Kabelka |
Denison
|
1:44.74 | 660 | +0.1% | SB | |
| 9 | Mick Bartholomew |
Kenyon
|
1:45.30 | 650 | -0.9% | ||
| 10 | Michael Crookshanks |
 Wooster
|
1:45.40 | 648 | – | PB | |
| 11 | Rip Lyster |
 Carnegie Mellon
|
1:45.92 | 638 | -3.2% | ||
| 12 | Samuel O'Malley |
Denison
|
1:47.39 | 612 | – | ||
| 13 | Eli Samuelson |
Wooster
|
1:51.45 | 548 | – | PB | |
| 14 | Nicholas Angeli |
 Wittenberg
|
1:52.35 | 535 | -0.7% | ||
| 15 | Matt Pech |
Wooster
|
1:53.62 | 517 | +1.0% | SB | |
| – | Weston Carpenter |
Kenyon
|
NS | – | – | ||
| – | Jacob Buckheit |
Carnegie Mellon
|
NS | – | – | ||
