| Name | Team | Time | Pts | Imp | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Francis Biagioli |
 Denison
|
4:02.02 | 696 | -0.9% | ||
| 2 | Ryan Anderson |
Denison
|
4:06.52 | 659 | +1.2% | SB | |
| 3 | Carter Brzezinski |
 Kenyon
|
4:08.07 | 646 | – | PB | |
| 4 | Oliver Waldram |
Denison
|
4:10.12 | 631 | +6.3% | PB | |
| 5 | Matthew Nardozzi |
 Allegheny
|
4:14.82 | 596 | -3.7% | ||
| 6 | Peyton Gaumer |
Denison
|
4:14.96 | 595 | -2.0% | ||
