| Name | Team | Time | Pts. | Imp. | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Samuel Cramer |
 Rider
|
15:30.49 | 799 | +0.2% | PB |
| 2 | Ryan Murphy |
 Marist
|
15:42.20 | 769 | +0.8% | SB |
| 3 | Collin Zapisek |
 Canisius
|
15:56.21 | 736 | +7.8% | PB |
| 4 | Miguel Basalo |
Marist
|
15:56.93 | 734 | +1.8% | PB |
| 5 | Christian Foti |
 Iona
|
15:58.01 | 732 | +2.2% | PB |
| 6 | Charles Broe |
 Bryant
|
16:10.67 | 704 | +4.9% | PB |
| 7 | Collin Purrman |
Iona
|
16:12.52 | 700 | +1.9% | SB |
| 8 | Alexander Pizzo |
 Niagara
|
16:16.19 | 692 | +3.3% | PB |
| 9 | James Pokornowski |
Canisius
|
16:24.38 | 675 | +4.3% | PB |
| 10 | Michael Regan |
Rider
|
16:25.15 | 673 | -0.0% | |
| 11 | Spencer Bray |
Canisius
|
16:26.75 | 670 | +3.1% | SB |
| 12 | Michael Berg |
Canisius
|
16:30.85 | 661 | +6.1% | SB |
| 13 | Evan Battisti |
 Manhattan
|
16:32.93 | 657 | – | |
| 14 | Brandon Shields |
Manhattan
|
16:33.12 | 657 | +5.2% | SB |
| 15 | Andrew Robinson |
 Fairfield
|
16:34.36 | 654 | +1.3% | SB |
| 16 | Oliver French |
Bryant
|
16:36.05 | 651 | +3.4% | PB |
| 17 | Riley Stadel |
Marist
|
16:36.90 | 649 | +2.5% | PB |
| 18 | Jamey Duncan |
Fairfield
|
16:42.40 | 639 | +0.9% | PB |
| 19 | Owen Badin |
Iona
|
16:49.91 | 625 | +3.0% | PB |
| 20 | Patrick Orkins |
Fairfield
|
16:59.99 | 606 | +6.5% | PB |
| 21 | Bryan Veals |
Iona
|
17:05.02 | 597 | +4.1% | SB |
| 22 | Chris Capparis |
Fairfield
|
17:05.91 | 596 | +2.6% | PB |
| 23 | Tanner Morey |
Niagara
|
18:04.79 | 504 | – | |
