| Rank | Name | Team | Time | Points | Improvement | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| – | Isabella Schultze | Denver Swim Academy | 1:57.67 | 640 | – | |
| – | Keara Reilly | Swim Dogs | 1:59.24 | 591 | -0.9% | |
| – | Amy Buker | Hilltop Aquatic Swim Team | 2:00.60 | 572 | +2.6% | PB |
| – | Victoria Vale | Denver Swim Academy | 2:00.60 | 560 | – | |
| – | Anna Gergely | University of Denver Hilltoppers | 2:01.12 | 549 | +1.4% | PB |
| – | Natassia Gorzen | Mesa Aquatics | 2:02.61 | 516 | -2.4% |
