| Name | Time | Score | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Emmanuel (A) | 40 | ||
| 2 | Wheeling (A) | 34 | ||
| 3 | Saint Andrews (A) | 32 | ||
| 4 | West Virginia Tech (A) | 30 | ||
| 5 | Urbana (A) | 28 | ||
| 6 | Union (KY) (A) | 26 | ||
| 7 | Mars Hill (A) | 24 | ||
| 8 | Asbury (A) | 22 | ||
| 9 | Notre Dame-OH (A) | 18 | ||
| 10 | Alderson Broaddus (A) | 14 | ||
| X | Wheeling (B) | – | ||
| X | West Virginia Tech (B) | – | ||
| X | Mars Hill (B) | – | ||
| X | Alderson Broaddus (B) | – | ||
| 11 | King (A) | 12 | ||
| X | Emmanuel (B) | – | ||
| 12 | LaGrange (A) | 10 | ||
