| Rank | Name | Team | Time | Points | Improvement | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Leo Johnson |
|
4:56.09 | 591 | +1.1% | SB |
| 2 | Pete Moyer |
|
4:58.77 | 575 | – | |
| 3 | Teague Sauter |
|
5:09.85 | 516 | – | |
| 4 | William James |
|
5:15.37 | 489 | – | PB |
| 5 | Jarrod Schwesinger |
|
5:15.43 | 489 | – | |
| 6 | Joshua Shenot |
|
5:41.48 | 385 | – |
