| Name | Team | Time | FINA | Imp | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Juan Morales |
 Colombia
|
3:58.77 | 783 | +1.3% | PB | |
| 2 | Daniel Jacobs |
 Aruba
|
4:01.25 | 759 | +1.8% | PB | |
| 3 | Carlos Vasquez |
 Honduras
|
4:08.23 | 697 | +0.3% | PB | |
| 4 | Graham Chatoor |
 Trinidad
|
4:08.61 | 694 | -1.0% | ||
| 5 | Julian Arazanzu Salazar |
Colombia
|
4:14.88 | 644 | – | ||
| 6 | Nicholas Vale |
 Jamaica
|
4:15.76 | 637 | -1.3% | ||
| 7 | Ethan Dyke-Elliott |
Saint Lucia
|
4:18.44 | 617 | +1.3% | PB | |
| 8 | Isacar Paula |
Curacaos
|
4:19.58 | 609 | +0.6% | PB | |
| Name | Team | Time | FINA | Imp | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Daniel Jacobs |
Aruba
|
4:12.58 | 661 | -2.8% | ||
| 2 | Carlos Vasquez |
Honduras
|
4:13.48 | 654 | -1.8% | ||
| 3 | Juan Morales |
Colombia
|
4:17.70 | 623 | -6.5% | ||
| 4 | Julian Arazanzu Salazar |
Colombia
|
4:17.95 | 621 | – | ||
| 5 | Graham Chatoor |
Trinidad
|
4:18.01 | 621 | -4.8% | ||
| 6 | Nicholas Vale |
Jamaica
|
4:18.74 | 615 | -2.5% | ||
| 7 | Ethan Dyke-Elliott |
Saint Lucia
|
4:20.06 | 606 | +0.7% | PB | |
| 8 | Isacar Paula |
Curacaos
|
4:20.96 | 600 | +0.0% | PB | |
| 9 | Luke-Kennedy Thompson |
 Bahamas
|
4:21.97 | 593 | -1.4% | ||
| 10 | Armando Alexis Montes |
 El Salvador
|
4:22.90 | 587 | +1.4% | SB | |
| 11 | Evan Farrow |
Bermuda
|
4:30.92 | 536 | – | ||
| 12 | Yael Touw Ngie Tjouw |
 Surinamese
|
4:31.12 | 535 | – | ||
| 13 | Trent Albury |
Bahamas
|
4:31.93 | 530 | -2.9% | ||
| 14 | Jordane Payne |
Jamaica
|
4:40.80 | 481 | – | ||
| – | Abrahan FLORES |
Honduras
|
NS | – | – | ||
| – | Jayhan Jamaud ODLUM-SMITH |
Saint Lucia
|
NS | – | – | ||
